Apples and oranges. You won't know unless you try.
People who hold a ton of water weight are fat plain and simple. I find it hard to believe anyone kept all the weight from any cycle but ok.
Also some people are more prone to water retention, but diet, aromatizing, water intake, type of training, and many other factors can play a role. No one can tell you which is better for you.
With drol, people usually love it or hate it due to sides, same with dbol.