have another odd question

[stevemorse0]

I was thinking, a dangerous thing for me, however lets throw this out.

Have you ever know or is it possible for someone lets do it in two cases :

someone is 140 lbs , lifts weights heavy to build, loses weight to 130 lbs, gains bodyfat? In otherwords for someone who works out hard is it possible to lose weight but gain bodyfat.

Now take a regular person, light bullcrap walking for exercise. Loses weight but puts on bodyfat?


Does everyone who lose weight automatically lose bodyfat???? I do get that they may all lose muscle when losing weight. But aside from Is it possible to lose weight and gain bodyfat???

 

[Massive123]

Sounds unlikely. It would seem someone who's losing weight would be burning more fat than muscle. Some muscle loss is possible but IMO fat comes off first and maybe some muscle but not really how you've put it, no

 

[stevemorse0]

thanks I did not think so. There may be one exception and thats as we age. We could probably lose weight and gain bodyfat thru 20 years of aging. Your weight may be less then when you were 30 but more bodyfat less weight at age 55.

 

[Miss Muscle]

I don't think so. I can't see how that would be possible. Even when aging I can't see how that would be possible.

I suggest you post this in training and diet as well...you may get more responses there!

 

[juced_porkchop]

you may just think you have/had more mucle then you do due to the mucle having a layer of fat around it.
but no usually fat then muscle or both at same time.