Thanks for all the input guys. After doing quite a bit of online research and some help from yawl, I am going to start taking the following:
Vitamin D3 - 5000 iu/day
Astaxanthin 12mg/day (not related to Test, but might help with some joint pain I have)
fish oil with 500mg EPA 250 DHA - my blood test showed that my HDL is 60 which is borderline too low
Multivitamin that includes 25mg zinc/day
melatonin 5mg/night to help with sleep
In addition I will try to find a gym to join to start doing some weight lifting because I read that lifting heavy weights at low reps can help increase T. I know my overall number isn't bad but my free Test is pretty low.
I guess I will try the above and get retested again in about 3 months, or not if I feel great.
All of the above being said I hate to see the $500 I spent on the blood tests and physical go to waste by not following through on the program - I guess thats just the inner cheap bastard in me. (logical me learned in econ 101 not to consider sunk costs when making a decision)