Which one are you?

balboa270

Amateur Bodybuilder
Very simply, let’s define them both here:

* Bodybuilding: sport where the goal is aesthetics, to look muscular, lean, larger and “ripped”. Competitions are judged by who looks better…
* Powerlifting: sport where the goal is to lift the heaviest weight in one of three of the powerlifts, bench press, deadlift or squat. Competitions are judged by who lifts more…

Another way to define them is that bodybuilders prance around on stages in little bikinis with fake tans and oil all over their bodies… and… powerlifters eat McDonalds every day, shave their heads and grow gotees. But let’s look a little deeper…

Difference In Exercises

You would think the two sports would be similar because they’re both about lifting weights right? Well, the differences in exercise choice are probably the first thing you’ll notice between the two.

Bodybuilders generally employ a different exercise for each and every part of their body to try to build it up and get it larger and more ripped. On “Chest day” for instance they might do bench presses, incline bench presses, dumbbell flyes, and then finish up with a pec dec machine or something like that.

Powerlifters stick more to the basics of the squat, deadlift and bench press — with any “assistance work” (i.e. other exercises) being focused on making those lifts better. Either extra exercises or variations on those movements to “work” certain parts of the lifts. For example: low box squats with a pause in the bottom position to train to get stronger out of the deep, bottom position of the squat.
Training Philosophies

For bodybuilders, it’s all about “how can I look better–get more development” and strength is a by-factor or secondary concern. It’s about how much muscle can I gain while losing a lot of fat so I can get huge, ripped, and vascular (veiny).

For powerlifters it’s all about how much weight can I lift. How can I get stronger… how can I improve my technique… how can I get better than the next guy at putting more weight on the bar and lifting it.
Nutrition

You’ll hear many bodybuilding pros say that nutrition is 80% of bodybuilding because what you put into you mouth has a BIG effect on the fat that gathers around your waist… or the muscle that grows on your biceps. So nutrition is a big part of bodybuilding and always will be, because the focus is on looking large and strong but with very low bodyfat.

In Powerlifting, nutrition is seen as a part of being in the right weight class at the meets. If you are a lighter lifter then it’s important to eat healthy to stay in the lighter weight class — yet the emphasis on nutrition is still on fueling your athletic performance.

For the heavy weight lifters it’s no-holds barred when it comes to food. Here’s some real advice from some of the strongest powerlifters who ever lived:

“I asked Dave Tate what he thought about nutrition. He rolled his eyes at me and walked away… Later he said, ‘Nutrition is overrated!’ Louie Simmons added only this, ‘Cholesterol turns into Testosterone!’”

— Doug Jackson from “Getting Schooled Westside Style”

“The nutrition thing has been blown way out of control. While you should eat healthy foods, you don’t have to eat like a bodybuilder. I’d bet most of the lifters we have get less than one gram per pound of body weight of protein, and eat whatever they want. The cleanest eating people I know are also some of the weakest. This is why we don’t say a lot about it. If it was important as the mags say it is, then I’d have the information all over the site. We’re here to help you get better, not feed you a bunch of supplement and nutrition BS.”

— Dave Tate from the EliteFTS Q&A

“I don’t like to write about the overrated topic of nutrition. Training is 99% of the battle.”

— Dave Tate from the EliteFTS Q&A

Why I Like Powerlifting Stuff

While I have no intentions of getting as big wide as I am tall, shaving my head and growing a gotee (oops! Already got one of those!) I like powerlifting.

Why? Bunch a reasons:

* Focus on strength: strength is the basis of all other physical skills (and building it builds mental strength too).
* Emphasis on posterior chain: most bodybuilders only work the muscles they can see in the mirror, i.e. pecs and “guns”. Powerlifting focuses a lot on getting the backside of your body strong which is good for your overall athletic performance and especially back health.
* Lifting heavy stuff is cool: nuff said
* They don’t do bicep curls in the squat rack.
* Emphasis on technique: to get heavy weights up you gotta have technique or you get seriously hurt
* Builds a good base: most people don’t know it but virtually all the world-champ bodybuilders started out in powerlifting and olympic weight lifting

Which One For You?

You probably don’t fall into either category completely. You probably don’t want to get “freaky huge” like professional bodybuilders and you probably don’t want to set a new world record in the squat or deadlift…

My guess is you’d like to be a little healthier, a little stronger, a whole lot leaner and just feel good about yourself. Am I right?

Leave me a comment to let me know what your goals are — whether you’re interested more in powerlifting or bodybuilding — and what you want to achieve!
 
re

Love powerlifting....fucking rediculous that its not in the olympics...and im talking about real powerlifting like in the IPF! However i think the sport would do better if they got rid of all the suits and shirts and briefs shit.

That being said, powerlifting is a tough sport, constantly putting your body under such heavy poundages can take a toll on your knees, back, shoulders etc. I did it for a while and loved it. Looking back i realize I overtrained and developed some injuries because of it though and that is my own fault. However it cant be healthy to put 600 pounds plus on your back, no matter how sound your training is.....just think of the amount of compression that is going on in your discs!!

Also, there is almost no fan base or money in powerlifting....and atm the future isn't looking any better for it (very unfortunate). Therefore i think alot of guys that could have been elite powerlifters choose bodybuilding instead.... just my 2 cents!!
 
The older I get the more I'm into bodybuilding. Right now I'm training around a broken left shoulder, arthritis, and two herniated discs. The discs were in 2003, the shoulder May last year. The shoulder X rays still showed a clean break in Aug. of this year. I don't concern myself with lifting more than the next guy,- I'm sure his bones are in better condition than mine. So things being the way they are, I lift with strict form on all reps. If I tried to powerlift now, I'd end up in traction in the hospital.:help:
 
baseball for me mainly, then id say to look good, note huge but to have more of a id say male fitness model look note super huge but way big enough for ppl to notice and like what they see but mainly to get to pro level ball
 
I switch back and forth every 3-4 months between bodybuilding and powerlifting routines. I like to consider myself somewhere in the middle. I am definitely concerned with aesthetics but also strength. Always try to eat clean 95 percent of the time. Good post balboa.
 
Half assed bodybuilding...not going to compete ever..and don't want to be goliath..

just satisfied is my goal...haha, is that possible?:bootyshak
 
Started off really just wanting the looks, but then I started working out with this old power lifter in my gym that out lifts everyone. I was embarrassed to even work out with him because of how big I am but how weak i was in the gym. But after i started working out with him (power lifting style) my lifts went through the roof and it felt pretty damn good to look around and I am out lifting almost everyone. Shit i had never even dead lifted and was scared to even try at first scared of hurting the back but now it is my favorite lift and I even out lift him in it. So now i have a hard time figuring out what i really want but i like the guy above said I have kind of started 3 or 4 months of cycle back and forth on training style.
 
Body builders lift impress women.
Power lifters lift to impress men.

I lift to look good, I could care less if I can lift up a car, what good will that do me?
Id rather reel in a whole mess of gorgeous women by having low bf and looking ripped.


my .02
 
Started off really just wanting the looks, but then I started working out with this old power lifter in my gym that out lifts everyone. I was embarrassed to even work out with him because of how big I am but how weak i was in the gym. But after i started working out with him (power lifting style) my lifts went through the roof and it felt pretty damn good to look around and I am out lifting almost everyone. Shit i had never even dead lifted and was scared to even try at first scared of hurting the back but now it is my favorite lift and I even out lift him in it. So now i have a hard time figuring out what i really want but i like the guy above said I have kind of started 3 or 4 months of cycle back and forth on training style.

What you said is why is started this thread. Anyways guys like arnold and franco where known for power lifting styles
 
I have to keep telling myself that I'm NOT a power lifter and focus on "the pump" and proper form. For some reason I always want to lift heavy but no it does no good for what I'm trying to do.

So, I'm focusing on bodybuilding but at heart a power lifter. Thats why I love being ON cycle due to the fact that I recover quicker and can go heavier with injury.
 
How much cardio do typical powerlifters do? Crap, I can't imagine too much. I guess I would fall on the bodybuilder side of your question. Maybe its time to consider changing sides.
 
Body builders lift impress women.
Power lifters lift to impress men.

I lift to look good, I could care less if I can lift up a car, what good will that do me?
Id rather reel in a whole mess of gorgeous women by having low bf and looking ripped.


my .02

this ^^^^ very true what good is it to b super strong? more ppl will look and talk about you if u got a bangin body. who is gonna talk about the power lifter? :beertoast
 
Good post.

I remember when I was maybe 5 years old I went to the movies with my dad. The movie was Predator.

After seeing Arnold that 1st time I wanted to be a body builder. T2 only reinforced that.

Years later I found myself watching "Pumping Iron" and reading his book.

I guess now that I'm a little older I realize you can't have great muscle definition w/o great muscles.... So I guess I'm a powerlifter who is waiting to cut.
 
Good post.

I remember when I was maybe 5 years old I went to the movies with my dad. The movie was Predator.

After seeing Arnold that 1st time I wanted to be a body builder. T2 only reinforced that.

Years later I found myself watching "Pumping Iron" and reading his book.

I guess now that I'm a little older I realize you can't have great muscle definition w/o great muscles.... So I guess I'm a powerlifter who is waiting to cut.
Conan did me in I was like wtf wow
 
Back
Top