Worst Decision/Judging ever in MMA

[dirkdiggler9969]

I just got done rewatching the Matt Hamil Michael Bisping fight and it got me thinking about this. I beleive that this was the worst decision I've seen in MMA. This is the first time I have rewatched the fight. I watched it live and remember being outraged with the decision. This time I got to watch it with the mindset of watching Bisping to see if I could give him a round. I couldn't. Fucking Cecil Peoples scored the fight 29-28 Bisping. What the fuck was he watching? How could you possibly have Bisping winning 2 fucking rds? He got absolutely dominated in the 1st and 3rd rd and I think he clearly lost the 2nd rd as well. Cecil Peoples seems to be the worst UFC judge to me. Usually someone says that boxing judges shouldn't be MMA judges because of their lack of knowledge in the ground/takedown game but Hamil clearly won the stand up in that fight.

Anyways, what fight comes to mind when you think of blown judging? Let's keep it to MMA, boxing has always been too corrupt and has soooooo many to choose from.

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

Also, Michael Bisping is a fucking douche. He acting like he dominated that fight in his interview. " I think I clearly won the stand-up" and "I think I did a really good job stoping the takedowns" (he got taken down like 6 times and stuffed about 4 takedowns in the 3rd period) and of course "Go back to wrestling" (with a hand jester for Matt Hamil to go away) I started my backround with wrestling and I'll be the first to say that 90 percent of Hamil's fights are boring but he did it all in the Bisping fight. He seems like an ass already on the TUF show too. Sorry to tangent on but that fight pissed me off all over again.

 

[duey]

i thought he lost that fight as well, and i agree is is a cocky douche

 

[ManOfMuscle]

Most recent one I can think of was the Sam Stout/Matt Wiman decision last saturday. Wiman got fucking robbed. He clearly took rounds 1 and 3.

 

[ManOfMuscle]

Next one that comes to mind is Nate Diaz vs. the human seatbelt (Clay Guida). Guida won the fight by hanging on to Diaz's back in a standing position for minutes at a time.

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

Human Seatbelt in nice. He looks exactly like Stuttering John from the Howard Stern Show.

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

Here is some pics... you decide. (I posted 2 of Guida hehe)

 

[JayC]

Totally agree on the Bisping and Stout/Wiman fights.. Ones that come directly to mind for me recently was that Last Karo Parisyan fight against that Korean Dong Kim.. the Korean got robbed but not without payback..lol I recently heard that the AC overturned it and called it a NC because that was when Karo tested positive for pain killers or something..

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

Haha. I have a buddy who was on the USA team for Judo in the Olympics and he said Karo was the laziest piece of shit he ever trained with. As I was laughing he said that Brandon Vera was a close second. It makes sense when you watch them fight. Tons of talent, bad conditioning and heart.

 

[JayC]

Haha. I have a buddy who was on the USA team for Judo in the Olympics and he said Karo was the laziest piece of shit he ever trained with. As I was laughing he said that Brandon Vera was a close second. It makes sense when you watch them fight. Tons of talent, bad conditioning and heart.

LOL.. Aint that the truth though! I've always said, most of the guys with the natural talent are lazy, have no work ethic or dedication, and usually come with tons of attitude/disrespect.. but the guy who just desires to play cuz he loves the sport, is gong to be the most dedicated and hardest worker out there and wont stop until he achieves each goal.

 

[ManOfMuscle]

LOL.. Aint that the truth though! I've always said, most of the guys with the natural talent are lazy, have no work ethic or dedication, and usually come with tons of attitude/disrespect.. but the guy who just desires to play cuz he loves the sport, is gong to be the most dedicated and hardest worker out there and wont stop until he achieves each goal.

A guy like John Fitch vs. a guy like BJ Penn.

 

[JayC]

A guy like John Fitch vs. a guy like BJ Penn.

Pefect example!!
..and GSP is just the rare exception to that rule. He actually has talent and desire/work ethic..IMO

 

[ManOfMuscle]

Pefect example!!
..and GSP is just the rare exception to that rule. He actually has talent and desire/work ethic..IMO

Definitely. I think all three p4p greats (anderson, gsp, fedor) have that quality.

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

I don't know about Fedor being dedicated. I'm pretty sure he's a cyborg sent from outer space, sent here to drink vodka and knock people dead all while looking like an unassuming bar patron.

 

[ManOfMuscle]

I've never seen him gas, and his technical grappling is second to none.

 

[coldblood303]

I don't know about Fedor being dedicated. I'm pretty sure he's a cyborg sent from outer space, sent here to drink vodka and knock people dead all while looking like an unassuming bar patron.

he does doesnt he? like some dude they just hauled in off the nearest bus stop..

 

[dirkdiggler9969]

If I didn't know better, I would steal Fedor if he said something to me at the wrong time. Then, after I got done looking for my shattered handbone fragments, I'd beg him to let me live.