speeddemon
Expert lifter
Huge assumption. The mentzer rotuine will in fact increase strength....up to a point. Too bad about it not increasing size nearly as well.
I guess the 3 sets of 10, and the 45-60 reps per bodypart, 2x per week evidence from the scientific community is right.
Assuming your diet is what kept you from gaining size is a HUGE assumption. Any moderate volume training will increase size with strength. It's the drastic, over the top HIT dudes that get stronger and say "just wait until the size gains come!" They won't. The body won't increase the size of the muscles with that little volume.
It is precisely why Dorian Yates took little to no info from mentzers abbreviated routines. Also why Yates trained ech bodypart once every 6 days. I saw you say it takes 2 weeks to recover a muscle group? Post the studies. It doesn't take anywhere NEAR that. Not even half that for most people. 5-6 days is a sweet spot for a reason.
I'd be happy to talk HIT training with anyone, I've only been doing it for 1.5 decades. EVERY iteration imaginable, with myself and others. I grow best in size/strength on 3 sets of 8-10, total volume of about 60-90 reps per body part, and best strength on 2 work sets of 5-8 reps....MAX-OT + a few reps. Hitting each body part every 5-7 days on both. REALLY like a push/pull/legs split training every other day indefinitely. (each bp every 6 days)
thanks